Skip to content

Guide: accreditation

Accredited and non-accredited ISO certification: the difference

Two certificates can have almost the same name and still prove different things. This guide explains what accreditation is, who grants it and which certificate you need for which purpose.

Start assessment

Your customer requires an audit or an accredited certification? Clarify requirements

01: Comparison

The difference at a glance

Both options side by side. Costs are guide figures for a small company, not quotes.

Accredited and non-accredited certification compared
FeatureAccreditedNot accredited (Zertify)
What it provesAn on-site audit of the management system by an accredited body, with annual surveillanceA passed self-assessment against the standard, reviewed by a member of the SICE Certification Board before issuance
RecognitionInternational, through accreditation agreementsEvidence for customers, no formal recognition
TendersUsually acceptedNot suitable when accreditation is required
CostInitial audit several thousand CHF, plus annual surveillanceCHF 599 to 849 in the first year, then CHF 399 to 569 per year
DurationSeveral months, depending on maturityCertificate usually within 4 hours of payment
EffortDocumentation, internal audit, management review, audit days32 to 48 questions, 20 to 30 minutes
Validity3 years, with annual surveillance audits3 years, with an annual online re-audit

02: Definition

What accreditation means

Accreditation is formal confirmation that a body is technically competent and impartial. In ISO certification your company is never the one accredited. The certification body that examines your management system is. For certifiers of management systems the benchmark is ISO/IEC 17021-1.

In each country a state-recognised accreditation body does this job. It assesses certification bodies regularly and can withdraw their recognition. ISO itself issues no certificates and accredits no one. It writes the standards.

03: Bodies

Who accredits: the accreditation bodies

For Switzerland, Germany, Austria and France, four bodies are responsible. An accredited certification body carries the mark of its accreditation body and appears in that body's public register.

SAS, Switzerland
The Swiss Accreditation Service SAS is part of the State Secretariat for Economic Affairs SECO. It accredits certification bodies in Switzerland.
DAkkS, Germany
Deutsche Akkreditierungsstelle DAkkS is Germany's national accreditation body.
Akkreditierung Austria
Akkreditierung Austria is Austria's state accreditation body.
COFRAC, France
The Comité français d'accréditation, COFRAC for short, accredits certification bodies in France.

The national bodies are linked through multilateral agreements under IAF and EA. A certificate from an accredited body is therefore usually recognised in all participating countries. Whether a body is accredited for your standard and your sector is shown in the database of the accreditation body concerned.

04: Accredited

What an accredited certificate means

An accredited certificate proves an audit carried out under recognised rules: stage 1 and stage 2, sampling on site, nonconformities found and corrected. It is valid for three years. In years one and two the body returns for surveillance audits to check that you still run the system.

Public authorities, large groups and contracting bodies usually accept such a certificate without further questions, across borders too. That comes at a price. You need documented processes, an internal audit, a management review and several days with auditors on your premises.

Check the scope. A certification body is only ever accredited for particular standards and sectors. If the scope on the certificate does not match your business, a customer's purchasing department can reject it. The logo alone tells you little. What counts is what the accreditation covers.

05: Not accredited

What a non-accredited certificate means

A non-accredited certificate comes from a body without accreditation. What it proves depends on the provider's procedure. At Zertify it proves that your company passed a structured self-assessment against the standard: 32 to 48 yes/no questions depending on the standard, with yes to all must-meet questions. A member of the SICE Certification Board checks the answers for plausibility before issuance. Zertify issues the certificate under licence from SICE.

It does not prove that anyone inspected your premises, and it carries no formal recognition through accreditation agreements. There is no audit, and SICE is not an accredited body. Other non-accredited providers work differently; some review documents remotely, for example. With every quote, ask exactly what is checked and who stands behind it.

What matters is that a certificate states openly what it is based on. At Zertify, the public verification page shows the standard, status and validity of every certificate.

06: Tenders

Tenders and customer requirements: what is really asked for

In public tenders the requirement sits in the selection criteria. Contracting authorities often ask for evidence of a quality management system, for example an ISO 9001 certificate from an accredited body. If the documents explicitly say accredited, a certificate based on a self-assessment does not meet the requirement. If they only ask for evidence of conformity with the standard, many companies use such a certificate as well.

Some contracting authorities accept equivalent evidence, such as a description of your quality assurance measures. What counts as equivalent is decided by the contracting authority case by case. Not by you and not by us. Settle it in writing before you submit your bid.

Large corporate customers work in a similar way. The requirement is in the supplier manual and is checked during supplier approval. A certificate that purchasing rejects only costs you time there. A short email to purchasing beforehand settles the question.

Rule of thumb: if the documents use the word accredited, you need accredited certification. If they only mention evidence of ISO 9001, ask what they mean.

07: Myths

Four common misconceptions

Some assumptions about accreditation are persistent. They lead to expensive wrong decisions.

Every ISO certificate is accredited
No. Whether a certificate is accredited depends on the body that issues it. The term ISO certificate says nothing about it.
Accredited means ISO has checked
No. ISO only publishes the standard. The certification body does the checking, and the accreditation body supervises its work.
A logo on the website proves accreditation
No. Logos can be copied. Only the entry in the accreditation body's register is reliable.
Not accredited means useless
No. The certificate lacks the formal recognition that accreditation brings. For customer evidence and internal order it can still be enough.

With these four points in mind you will ask every provider the right questions. Us included.

08: Decision

Decide in five questions

Work through the questions in order. For the first two, a single yes often settles it.

  1. Does a law, a contract or a tender require accredited certification?

    Then you need it. Get quotes from accredited bodies.

  2. Does a major customer require it in its supplier rules?

    Ask whether equivalent evidence is accepted. If the answer is no, you need an accredited body.

  3. Do you need the evidence for quotes, questionnaires and your website?

    Then a self-assessment certificate is often enough, as long as you label it openly as such.

  4. Do you have documented processes and time for an audit?

    Then accredited certification is well within reach. If both are missing, start with the self-assessment and build the system step by step.

  5. What is your budget for the first three years?

    If it is below the guide figure for an accredited initial audit plus surveillance, that route is hardly realistic. The cheaper evidence is then the sensible choice.

09: Questions

Frequently asked questions about accreditation

The quick evidence, openly labelled

The assessment is free. You pay only once you have passed.

Start assessment

Your customer requires an audit or an accredited certification? Clarify requirements

The certificate is based on a self-assessment and is not accredited.